Home › Prewarmed vs fresh
Compare
Prewarmed vs fresh inboxes
The same mailbox at two points in its life. Prewarmed sends on arrival; fresh is built on your own domain and you warm it up first. Which to buy is about your start date, not the price.
| Prewarmed | Fresh | |
|---|---|---|
| Delivered | Typically the same day | Within 48 to 72 hours |
| Ready to send | On arrival | After 14 to 21 days of warmup |
| Domain | Prewarmed .com or .co, aged 30 days + | Your own brand |
| Domain cost | Free | Bring your own free, or $12 one off |
| SPF, DKIM, DMARC and MX | Set before handover | Set before handover |
| Warmup tool | Not needed to start: warmed before delivery | Yours, from $97 a month |
| Google, per inbox per month | $8 to $6 | $3.50 to $2, by size and cycle |
The comparison people get wrong
Put the two per-inbox prices side by side and fresh wins easily, about a third of the prewarmed price at volume. That comparison treats them as the same product at different prices, and they are not. Prewarmed is a mailbox plus a domain that has already done its weeks, sending the day it lands. Fresh is a mailbox on your own domain that sends three weeks later.
Prewarmed typically arrives the same day and fresh within 48 to 72 hours, both with SPF, DKIM and DMARC set. Prewarmed has its warmup done before it reaches you. Fresh needs your own warmup tool, from about $97 a month, so on a small fleet that tool can cancel out the cheaper inbox price. The bigger difference is the calendar, and what three weeks of not sending costs your business.
When fresh is the right call
- Your first send is three weeks or more away, so the warmup fits inside time you already had.
- You want your own brand on the sending domain. Prewarmed inboxes stay on their prewarmed domain.
- You are adding capacity behind a fleet that is already sending, at the lower price per inbox.
And if you are somewhere in between, split it: buy prewarmed for what is live now and let a fresh batch on your own brand warm behind it.
When prewarmed is the right call
A client campaign that starts next week. A domain you have just retired and need capacity to replace this week. A launch date that is fixed and close. In each of those the cheaper line item is the more expensive decision, and the gap is not the price difference. It is the weeks of meetings you do not get.
Work out which you are
The calculator takes your daily send target and your launch date, sizes the infrastructure on each of the three platforms, prices both ways, and tells you whether fresh can reach your date at all.
The pages for each
Prewarmed: Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, Azure tenants, domains.
Fresh: Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, Azure tenants, domains.
Questions
What is the difference between prewarmed and fresh inboxes?
The same licensed mailbox, at two points in its life. Prewarmed arrives on a prewarmed domain that has already been aged 30 days and warmed 21, and sends on arrival. Fresh is built on your own domain, and you warm it up for 14 to 21 days on your own warmup tool before it sends.
How long until a fresh inbox can send cold email?
Once its warmup is done: 14 to 21 days after delivery. Fresh orders arrive within 48 to 72 hours of payment.
Do I need a warmup tool for fresh inboxes?
Yes. We do not run warmup on fresh inboxes, so you need a warmup tool, from about $97 a month, for 14 to 21 days before you send and kept running after. Prewarmed inboxes arrive with that done, and if you send them through an AI agent we can keep them warming in our own pool.
Is prewarmed worth the extra cost?
It depends on your start date. If you need to send this week, fresh cannot get there. If your launch is three weeks or more out, or you want your own brand on the domain, fresh is the better buy.
Can I mix the two?
That is what most teams sending seriously end up doing. Prewarmed for the campaign that starts now, fresh on their own brand warming behind it. It is cheaper than either extreme.